
An Australian business summit on productivity? It’s about time. Here are three fantasy agenda items
Guardian Australia
Guardian Australia
‘A more competitive economy’
This week, Coles’ chief executive, Leah Weckert, said with a straight face: “The grocery industry in Australia is unbelievably competitive.”
The consumer and competition watchdog in its February 2025 report had a very different take.
“Coles and Woolworths dominate the Australian grocery sector and this is set to continue. The supermarket industry is highly concentrated.”
Big business bosses must recognise that there is a severe lack of competition in Australia, and that this is harming productivity.
Research by the e61 Institute has found Australian industries have become more concentrated over the past 15 years. It found that established firms in these sectors are harder to displace, and that the number of new entrants tends to dwindle.
Bad for dynamism, bad for productivity.
More concentrated industries “often” display more anti-competitive behaviour, the researchers found, as measured by the number of infringements issued by the regulator. (Cue discussion around petrol stations’ pricing practices and bank royal commissions.)
What’s a potential remedy?
If we are looking at the national good, which of course we are, industry could throw its weight behind a special tax on “economic rents” – which happens to be the most efficient form of taxation.
These are the superprofits that accrue to those big firms operating in their walled gardens across sectors like mining and energy, supermarkets and banking.
The revenue could then be used to lower the rate of tax on income across all companies, offsetting the rent taxes to a degree and giving more dynamic firms a boost.
This is not a million miles away from a recent Productivity Commission proposal which was howled down by big business.
‘Better bosses for a better Australia’
Much was made of a recent Productivity Commission report which found that company boards spent more than half of their time on compliance – more than twice as much as a decade ago. That seems like too much.
What was less remarked upon was a damaging lack of quality among Australian managers.
The PC in its research found one study which estimated improving the standard of management could boost productivity by nearly 10% – a huge increase in a country struggling to record any lift in productivity.
This management issue has been raised at various times over the years.
“Many businesses are good at identifying opportunities but less effective at implementing organisational change,” the PC report found, echoing Bullock’s comments that Aussie firms are not great at keeping up with the latest tech and trends.
As the government’s top independent economic adviser, the commission had a range of suggestions for how policymakers could help the business sector lift the standard of managers.
But a productivity summit organised for and by corporate Australia would surely have many good suggestions about how to nourish its own employees.
And, speaking of management …
‘Accountable C-suite for an A-grade future’
Any honest self-appraisal by corporate Australia would conclude that the bosses at the very top of the ladder are paid way, way too much. And that they are not properly accountable for their company’s performance.
A study by the Australian Council of Superannuation Investors found that CEOs of the top 100 listed companies were more likely to lose their job than lose their bonus.
There was “clear evidence that CEO bonuses continue to be a ‘given’ in Australia’s largest companies”, ACSI found.
The middle-of-the-pack ASX 100 boss received total pay of $4.8m in 2024-25, which was 16% more than the previous financial year. It was also 48 times the salary of the median full-time Australian worker.
But what does executive remuneration have to do with a more dynamic economy?
Business investment outside the mining sector collapsed through the 2010s, and this spending drought helps explain our stagnating productivity.
An RBA study in 2023 found that “declining competition may have weakened firms’ incentives to improve and grow” (see “A more competitive economy”).
But the post-GFC period was also marked by an intense competition among big firms to return every last cent of profit to their shareholders.
It was the decade of corporate cash splashes through special dividends and share buybacks that drove up stock prices and executive bonuses alike.
The potential reward from making relatively risky investments in your own business could not compete with this rush to “maximise shareholder value”.
This attitude generated short-term gain but long-term pain.
The answer to this in corporate speak: Pay should be right-sized and then optimised so that leaders are rewarded for future-proofing their businesses through far-sighted capital expenditure.
In plain English: Invest more in your own business and people, even if it means you get a million dollars less this year.
AI Summary
This analysis examines Australia's lack of market competition, stagnant productivity, and poor management quality. It argues that high industry concentration, excessive executive pay, and short-term shareholder focus hinder long-term business investment.
Sentiment analysis
AI insights
low
15m ago
general
Financial analysis
Relevance
medium
Market sensitivity
medium
Affected sectors
Affected assets
Follow this story on TV
Live charts and AI commentary on one screen with Trade on tv.